Is Bane really that hard to get right?

Tom Hardy, Shane West and Robert Swenson

Out of the many beatings Batman has taken over the years, few have stung as much as the Knightfall saga. Arguably the defining story arc of 90's Caped Crusader comics, it is known best as the book in which Bane broke the Bat, cementing the muscular mastermind as one of his greatest adversaries. However, this iconic character has never quite met fans' expectations when it comes to his appearances in TV and film.

This week, Gotham writer/producer Tze Chun unveiled the first image of Shane West as Bane. This attempt at the villain's costume lacks all of the iconic features besides the tubes, making him completely unrecognisable. It's not necessarily a bad costume per se, but would it have been that much harder to stay true to the source material?

Bane breaks Batman's back in Knightfall

Bane's first live-action appearance was in the infamous Batman & Robin, only a few years after the conclusion of Knightfall. When it came to the costume, it wasn't too far off what fans were familiar with. Sure, it's a little silly by today's standards, but what matters is that the iconic lucha libre mask is there. This first Bane's major downfall was the writing, or lack of - his grandiose monologues were nowhere to be seen, reducing him to a mindless brute.

The character returned to the silver screen over a decade later in The Dark Knight Rises. This version was an improvement in terms of dialogue, but the strange choice of accent damaged the portrayal. Also, due to the realistic nature of the Dark Knight films, much of the comic book costume design was lost. The trench coat is pretty cool, however.

Will we ever see a Bane like this in live action?

Gotham had an opportunity to give us the most comic-accurate Bane yet. All it takes is to search "classic Bane cosplay" to see what could have been - it's a shame, as Professor Pyg and Scarecrow had excellent costumes. Of course, not all hope is lost. With the right script, "Bane West" could still give us a good performance in Gotham's final season.

Comments

Why One Piece's Whole Cake Island Arc was a real treat

Primary antagonist Big Mom One Piece 's Wano Arc is in full swing for both the manga and the anime series, and fans of Japan's favourite comic franchise are loving all of the spectacular samurai action - but let's not forget what came before! Before Luffy and the Straw Hat Pirates arrived in the Land of Wano, they were battling Emperor Big Mom on her home turf to free their chef Sanji from a forced marriage. So, looking back, just how good was the Whole Cake Island Arc ? The main thing that jumps out about Whole Cake is that it continues to burst with the creativity and flavour that make One Piece so beloved. Whole Cake Island itself is the centrepiece of an archipelago known collectively as Totto Land, each corresponding to a delicious treat, such as cheese, pie, biscuits and candy. These islands are populated by Big Mom's forces and various super-powered commanders, making it a daunting task for Luffy's rescue team to make it in and out unscathed. ...

Batman Day 2018: The Dynamic Duo Awards

DC's Caped Crusader might be the world's number-one favourite superhero, and today is the time of year where we take a moment to appreciate just how awesome this character is. Since his debut in spring 1939, Batman has starred in an abundance of iconic stories, some of which have been the topic of posts on this blog. For this reason, I thought I'd make it an annual tradition to round up all of my Bat-favourites on the Dark Knight's special day. However, I'm a strong believer that Batman needs a Robin, so I'm naming it the Dynamic Duo Awards and accompanying the winner of each category with a runner-up. Without further ado, let's light the Batsignal and begin! In a previous blog post , I declared Grant Morrison's run the ultimate Batman comic - but which parts did I like best? Well, it's Batman & Robin that I believe provided the greatest take on the Bat-mythos. Colourful and campy yet also dark and violent, this masterpiece i...

Grayson: The very essence of DC's former Boy Wonder

Art by Mikel Janin Out of every single superhero in comics, it is perhaps Dick Grayson who has gone through the most character development. After being the iconic sidekick Robin for four decades, he stepped out of the shadow of the Bat and became Nightwing, a change that has lasted until this day. Over the years, he has also taken on different personas, including picking up the mantle of Batman when Bruce Wayne was out of commission. After his identity was exposed in Forever Evil and the world believed him to be dead, Dick took on another guise: Agent 37 of Spyral, the shadowy intelligence organisation introduced in the pages of Batman Incorporated . This new chapter in his life was told by writers Tim Seeley and Tom King in Grayson , a brilliant spy saga that further establishes Dick as one of DC's greatest characters. Robin and Nightwing, Dick's previous guises As Agent 37, Dick has to balance tracking down superhuman criminals and his true goal of prov...

Paperback in Action

Search This Blog