Skip to main content

Is Bane really that hard to get right?

Tom Hardy, Shane West and Robert Swenson

Out of the many beatings Batman has taken over the years, few have stung as much as the Knightfall saga. Arguably the defining story arc of 90's Caped Crusader comics, it is known best as the book in which Bane broke the Bat, cementing the muscular mastermind as one of his greatest adversaries. However, this iconic character has never quite met fans' expectations when it comes to his appearances in TV and film.

This week, Gotham writer/producer Tze Chun unveiled the first image of Shane West as Bane. This attempt at the villain's costume lacks all of the iconic features besides the tubes, making him completely unrecognisable. It's not necessarily a bad costume per se, but would it have been that much harder to stay true to the source material?

Bane breaks Batman's back in Knightfall

Bane's first live-action appearance was in the infamous Batman & Robin, only a few years after the conclusion of Knightfall. When it came to the costume, it wasn't too far off what fans were familiar with. Sure, it's a little silly by today's standards, but what matters is that the iconic lucha libre mask is there. This first Bane's major downfall was the writing, or lack of - his grandiose monologues were nowhere to be seen, reducing him to a mindless brute.

The character returned to the silver screen over a decade later in The Dark Knight Rises. This version was an improvement in terms of dialogue, but the strange choice of accent damaged the portrayal. Also, due to the realistic nature of the Dark Knight films, much of the comic book costume design was lost. The trench coat is pretty cool, however.

Will we ever see a Bane like this in live action?

Gotham had an opportunity to give us the most comic-accurate Bane yet. All it takes is to search "classic Bane cosplay" to see what could have been - it's a shame, as Professor Pyg and Scarecrow had excellent costumes. Of course, not all hope is lost. With the right script, "Bane West" could still give us a good performance in Gotham's final season.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A thank-you to Steve Ditko

The late Steve Ditko was best known for creating Spider-Man with Stan Lee, and arguably shaped the entire world of superheroes when he did. While Clark Kent was the common man, Peter Parker was the common boy, making him a character that generations of new fans could connect with. Ditko's artwork was dynamic and fun, attracting more and more readers who previously wouldn't have given comics a second glance. His work lives on through new creators, and its influence can be felt in films based on his characters, such as the recent Spider-Man: Homecoming . Steve Ditko is also strongly associated with Charlton Comics - he created Captain Atom, the Question and Ted Kord, the second Blue Beetle. These heroes served as the inspiration for the characters of Alan Moore's  Watchmen , which showed the world that comics can be taken just as seriously as films and television. Ditko had no direct involvement with Watchmen , but it is another example of just how far his influence ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Crazy, epic and tragic: Reviewing Grant Morrison's Batman

"Batman always comes back, bigger and better, shiny and new. Batman never dies. It never ends. It probably never will." But if there ever was an ultimate Batman story, this would be it. Grant Morrison's legendary Batman saga ties all facets of the beloved Caped Crusader into a single tale, producing a piece of modern-day mythology that will define Gotham's protector for generations. Morrison's Batman tale ran for seven years in total, but its many nods to Gotham's past and hints towards its future make it feel like a comprehensive record of the Wayne legacy. When writing this epic, Morrison declared that all prior Batman stories did indeed happen, with his run being the focal point of them all. The adventure begins in Batman and Son , which throws us straight into the madness with a scene of a trigger-happy Batman attempting to kill the Joker, only to be stopped by...Batman? This introduces us to a central theme of the series: the bat used as a s...
Post a Comment
Read more

Are Kryptonians stronger than Saiyans?

Art by Brett Booth and Bruno Furlani One of Superman's greatest opponents is one he will never actually meet: Dragon Ball protagonist Son Goku. The outcome of this dream match-up has been hotly debated by fans of both manga and Western comics, with no concrete answer being universally agreed upon. In fact, the argument is so divisive that it is now banned from most comic book forums. Despite being a big fan of both characters, I've never been able to confidently bet on one hero over the other - until now. Perhaps the main reason why the debate continues to this day is that, by nature, each character keeps displaying new feats that could tip the scales. This is because of their alien physiology - Superman is Kryptonian and Goku is Saiyan, meaning they each have powers that put them at the very top of their respective fictional universes. Thus, the only way to truly end this mighty clash is not to focus solely on these heroes, but to look at the differences between each ex...
Post a Comment
Read more